| |
NPF Schemes
General
To talk to someone about your scheme, phone
0800 628 776
|
|
Investment Market Commentary
Investment – Quarter ended 30 June 2010The commentary features contributions from AMP Capital Investors. The views expressed are not necessarily the views of the Board of Trustees of the National Provident Fund.
Main themes for the June quarter
- Global shares reached a new cycle high in April as the global economic recovery gained traction. But throughout the remainder of the June quarter, sentiment and markets showed a significant deterioration.
- Debt concerns in Greece, Spain and Portugal raised risks of a contagion effect across Europe and, ultimately, the world. The market "forced" the hands of governments to implement fiscal austerity packages to bring government debt under control and the market worried about the impact of tighter fiscal policy on the growth outlook.
- Momentum in global leading economic indicators peaked out, policy tightening appeared to be working in China and a soft spot emerged in US housing and employment, leading some to believe that the risk of a double-dip recession was increasing. New Zealand's econoimic recovery remained on track, but was modest by historical standards.
- Global shares fell through May and June to be down 11.0% (MSCI World Index, local currency). New Zealand shares were dragged down by global forces, with the NZX 50 down 9.1%
- Expectations of interest rate increases in the G3 were pushed out to well into 2011. This, and the significant reduction in risk appetite, drove rates down to new lows. The US 10-year rate fell 89 basis points (bps) to below 3%. The Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) raised rates for the first time this cycle in June. The yield curve flattened significantly, with the NZ 90-day rate up 49 bps and the New Zealand 11-year rate down by 64 bps.
- There were some significant movements in cross rates, but these largely cancelled each other out. The New Zealand dollar (NZD) rose against the euro and Australian dollar but fell against the US dollar, yen and sterling, with the NZD down by only 1% on an MSCI-weighted basis.
Looking ahead
- While falling share prices and bond yields suggest improved equity valuations, even accounting for a weaker macro outlook, negative sentiment and reduced economic momentum (after a strong bounce post recession) cloud the near-term outlook for share markets.
- The fall in share prices and bond yields has improved the valuation of New Zealand shares. However, there are no obvious near-term catalysts to improve sentiment in the market and investors will have to be a little patient to realise better returns.
- When risk appetite returns, long term rates are expected to rise back towards where they were earlier in the year. That said, the latest risk event has delayed the time for higher policy rates in the major countries by several months and deflationary risks have increased, and these factors are supportive for bond rates.
- As for New Zealand interest rates, a series of rate rises are expected over coming quarters, putting upward pressure on the short end of the curve. While current sentiment is driving long term bond rates lower, a reversal of fortunes can be expected as risk appetite recovers.
- The NZD is highly correlated with global shares at the moment, moving up or down in line with risk appetite. That makes us cautious about the NZD in the near term, despite rising interest rate differentials in New Zealand’s favour being a supporting factor.
Economic Review
Global economic review and outlook
Review
- After a solid start to the year, economic growth indicators showed an increasing propensity to disappoint expectations, possibly reflecting an overshooting of previous upgrades to forecasts. This trend was most notable in the US. Furthermore, it was clear that growth momentum was fading, admittedly from a high base, in many countries, including China. Fiscal austerity was a key focus for governments in Europe to alleviate market fears about public debt spiralling out of control.
- In the US the removal of the home-buyers tax credit in April had a significant impact on activity data in the housing market. Existing and new home sales, housing starts, permits and builder’s confidence indicators all pulled back, some significantly so. Further questions were raised about the sustainability of economic recovery, with employment data surprising on the weak side and consumer confidence falling during June. Headline retail sales and durable goods orders both fell during June, but core levels for both series were in line with expectations. The all-important manufacturing ISM indicator fell slightly, but was consistent with solid growth in manufacturing. Industrial production continued its rising trend, up 7.6% year-on-year (YoY) in May. Inflation pressures remained very weak, with the core CPI rising by 0.9% YoY, equalling the lowest rate since the 1960s.
- The larger European nations joined in the fiscal austerity trend recently adopted by the smaller peripheral countries. Proposals in Germany and France were put forward to cut budget deficits, highlighting that tighter fiscal policy would be a headwind for growth in the region. The new government in the UK announced an emergency Budget designed to tighten fiscal policy by over 6% of GDP over five years. The debt concerns in Europe were beginning to have some impact on timely confidence indicators, but economic momentum in the region’s largest economy, Germany, remained good. Germany’s Ifo index rose to a two-year high and factory orders were strong, helping to drive a very strong 9.3% YoY increase in EU industrial production in April. Retail sales across the region remained weak, with real sales down 1.5% month-on-month in April. The unemployment rate in the region continued to rise, reaching 10.1% in April.
- In Asia, it was clear that tightening measures introduced in China were working, with the PMI tracking lower, suggesting that growth momentum was coming off its recent highs. Industrial production slowed to 16.5% YoY in May. By contrast, exports surged by 48.5% YoY in May, the largest gain in exports in six years and import growth was similarly strong. China’s CPI inflation reached a 19-month high of 3.1% YoY and there were also reports of strong wage increases for some manufacturers, adding to the concerns about inflation. A key policy announcement was that China’s central bank would proceed further with reform of the renminbi exchange rate and increase its flexibility.
- G3 central banks remained in no mood to tighten monetary policy in the current environment, although the Bank of Canada became the first G7 central bank to tighten monetary policy this cycle, raising its policy rate by 25 basis points (bps) to 0.5%
Outlook
Global growth momentum is slowing after a strong initial burst out of recession, but world GDP growth is still expected to comfortably exceed 4% this year. Europe is likely to remain a weak link and contagion risks to other areas remain a genuine threat to the global recovery. Growth momentum in the developing world is also slowing, but will remain well above developed world growth for many years to come.
New Zealand economic review and outlook
Review
-
New Zealand’s economic recovery continued, but surveys suggested higher levels of confidence and activity than currently suggested by the hard evidence.
- GDP rose for the fourth consecutive quarter, up 0.6% in the March quarter (up 1.9% YoY), confirming that New Zealand’s economic recovery remains on track, despite the growth pulse being weaker compared to other post-recession recoveries.
- The domestic economic growth pulse remained tepid, with retail sales ex-auto growth running a 1-1.5% and total sales up around 2.5-3%. The housing market was in a holding pattern, with the volume of house sales running at historically low levels, suggesting that the recent revival in dwelling consents might not be sustained.
- That said, business and consumer confidence remained elevated. Westpac’s consumer confidence index rose over the June quarter to maintain its above-average level. Confidence slipped off recent highs in the National Bank’s business outlook survey, but the own-activity indicator was still at levels consistent with GDP growth of almost 5%.
- New Zealand’s terms of trade rose by 5.8% quarter on quarter in the March quarter, suggesting that nominal GDP was tracking much better than the real GDP figures indicated. Improved pricing and stronger export volumes helped drive New Zealand’s current account deficit down to 2.4% of GDP in the March quarter, the best result in more than two decades.
-
As widely expected, the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) raised the Official Cash Rate (OCR) by 25 bps to 2.75%, the first rate increase this cycle. While the projections continued to show a gradually rising path for the 90-day bank rate (a similar end point to the previous Statement of just over 6%) the commentary on the policy outlook was fairly bland. The key comment was “… the further removal of stimulus will be reviewed in light of economic and financial market developments".
Outlook
New Zealand’s economy is likely to experience a broad based economic recovery in line with the global economy through 2010, with the strong terms of trade helping to boost incomes. GDP growth is expected to average 3.5% over 2010 and 2011.
Investment markets
New Zealand shares
Review
- New Zealand shares corrected materially over the June quarter. The NZX 50 fell 9.1%. The correction came off the back of weak global economic data from the US and Europe and an increased risk aversion in response to the sovereign risk issues in Europe. The MSCI World Index fell 11.0% in local currency terms.
- Markets are increasingly focused on policy risk which prompts the question: What are the appropriate policy settings and how will economies and markets react to those settings? The trade-off between an easier policy supporting economic activity and a tighter policy controlling public debt levels is a challenging one for most developed economies.
- Earnings reports and guidance were a major driver of relative performance. Skellerup was notable for a material increase in earnings guidance.
Outlook
Despite the economic potholes revealed over the quarter the strong outlook for emerging economies should underpin the global economic recovery. Developed economies have a less robust outlook than previously forecasted with Europe at risk of contraction.
The decline of both share prices, interest rates and tax rates in New Zealand, has improved the valuation support for New Zealand shares. While the earnings outlook is increasingly challenging New Zealand shares provide an attractive return/risk outlook.
New Zealand cash and fixed interest
Review
- The June quarter produced a dramatic change in global sentiment. From a new cycle high in April, share markets quickly fell as debt concerns in Europe increased. Peripheral Europe (PIIGS) yields rose quickly as the chance of default increased (supported by sovereign credit rating downgrades of some of these members). Central European yields fell as a slowing growth, low inflation, picture emerged.
- Slowing world growth became the dominant theme for the rest of the quarter. This was further supported with US data tending to be weaker than anticipated by the market and accompanied with weaker company reporting.
- China also showed signs that recent policy tightening is beginning to work, with the edge being taken off recent data.
- New Zealand data continued to support a recovery, although slower than in previous cycles. Unsurprisingly, the RBNZ raised the Official Cash Rate (OCR) in June to 2.75% from 2.50%. This is the first change since April 2009 and marks the beginning of the removal of stimulus.
Short term rates for both government bonds and swaps rose during the quarter in line with the actions of the RBNZ.
Long term rates fell aggressively as global rates fell, triggered by the European debt crisis.
The cost for non-governments (including banks) to borrow rose back towards 2009 peaks.
Outlook
- New Zealand’s broad based recovery is likely to continue and GDP is expected to average 3.5% over 2010 and 2011. This should be in line with global growth of around 4%, largely as a result of Asia and emerging markets. European growth remains the weak link and is at risk of spreading debt concerns to other developed regions.
- The RBNZ is expected to raise the OCR by 25 bps at each meeting, until it reaches 4.50% in 2011. The main risks to this interest rate track are around the ability of the New Zealand banks to fund their activities. The current debt concerns in Europe have closed credit markets and access to funds. This should be temporary, but it is possible it will continue for an indefinite period. Higher funding costs would remove the need for the RBNZ to raise the OCR to the same extent.
- Long term rates remain attractive and are significantly higher than short term rates. This difference is expected to reduce. Most likely it will be through the continued rise in the OCR with short term rates rising. However, if there is contagion to global growth from the European crisis, it may be through long term rates continuing their recent falls.
International fixed interest
Review
- The increased risk of a lower than expected global growth outlook renewed the bond market rally and international bond yields fell across the board in the June quarter.
- The US 10 year bond yield fell by 89 bps to 2.94% and Japan’s 10 year bond yield fell by 31 bps to close at 1.09%. In Europe, the UK 10 year bond yield fell by 58 bps to close the month at 3.36% and Germany’s 10 year bond yield fell by 51 bps to 2.58%.
- The continuing eurozone sovereign crisis triggered a wider bout of risk aversion which, along with concerns that austerity measures in Europe would dampen European Union and world growth prospects, resulted in a flight to quality in the government bond market.
Outlook
- Europe’s sovereign debt crisis has seen investors pursue ‘safe havens’ in German Bonds and US Treasuries. The crisis is likely to gradually abate, provided that the package developed by the European Union and the International Monetary Fund stabilises the vulnerable countries and prevents them from infecting global growth. Later in 2010 and 2011, rising private credit demand and the legacy of funding large budget deficits are expected to produce modest upward pressure on sovereign bond yields.
- As credit spreads return to the more ‘normal’ levels, typically seen through economic downturns, investors are expected to revert to a more stock-specific focus. The pace of spread tightening should begin to ease over the short term, as mutual fund inflows into investment grade credit appear to be slowing. The ‘yield dilemma’ remains in many developed countries, i.e. the yield on credit is beginning to appear less compelling due to base government bond yields, while longer term spreads remain wide compared to previous cycles and appear to provide attractive entry points into non-financial credit spreads. Lower-quality issuers, particularly those in cyclical industries which are traditionally more exposed to periods of economic contraction, will likely be most impacted by global economic events. However, many strong companies have been caught up in market repricing as well, with spreads widening beyond levels that are appropriate from a fundamental viewpoint in many cases. From a risk-adjusted return perspective, the prospects for these investments over the medium term look to be attractively priced.
International shares
Review
- International shares, and particularly Chinese shares, suffered a sharp correction during the June quarter, impacted by concerns over global growth being hampered by austerity measures throughout Europe, continuing sovereign debt concerns in the eurozone and a slowdown in China due to its recent monetary policy tightening.
- The leading measure of global share market performance, the MSCI World Gross Accumulation Index, returned -11.0% in local currencies (or -9.9% in unhedged NZD terms). The US S&P 500 Accumulation Index returned -11.4% in local currency terms. In the European region, the Eurostoxx Accumulation Index returned -9.3% in local currencies and the UK FTSE 100 Accumulation Index returned -12.6% in local currency terms. Shares in Asia also suffered with Japan’s Topix Accumulation Index returning -13.9% and China’s S&P/CITIC 300 Total Return Index returning -22.4%.
Outlook
Global growth momentum is slowing after a strong initial burst out of recession, but world GDP growth is still expected to comfortably exceed 4% this year. Europe is likely to remain a weak link and contagion risks to other areas remain a genuine threat to the global recovery. Growth momentum in the developing world is also slowing, but will remain well above developed world growth for many years to come.
Global property
Review
- In Asia, the UBS Asia ex Australia Investors Index returned -3.2% in local currency terms. Hong Kong was Asia’s strongest performer, outperforming the broader share market on the back of better than expected news on the residential front and stronger fundamentals. Meanwhile, Japanese real estate stocks were the region’s worst performer, underperforming the broader equity market and giving back recent gains amid company downgrades and weaker than expected economic and real estate data.
- In Australia, the UBS Australia Investors Index returned -1.4% in local currency terms.
- European real estate securities returned -10.6% in local currencies, as per the UBS Europe Investors Index. European real estate securities outperformed the broader share market over the quarter. Investor sentiment continued to be broadly affected by macroeconomic events, including the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico and continued pressure on credit spreads.
- In North America, the UBS US/Canada Investors Index returned -4.2% in local currencies. Investor uncertainty carried over into June amid the ongoing European debt crisis, fears for China’s economy, proposed US financial regulation reform and the escalating clean-up and cost of BP’s oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. While this uncertainty weighed on investor sentiment, defensive REIT sectors nonetheless remained in favour. Notably, US REITs fared significantly better than general equities during the June quarter.
Outlook
- Investor uncertainty will remain until macro economic issues are resolved
New Zealand dollar
Review
- The New Zealand dollar (NZD) fell by 1% on an MSCI-weighted basis over the June quarter, with divergent cross rates largely cancelling each other out.
- The euro was particularly weak, as investors worried about the size of the fiscal deficit and debt of some of the European Monetary Union countries and the ability of those governments to issue new debt at reasonable interest rates. Countries like Greece, Portugal and Spain were seen to be weak links in the euro area and a possible source of financial instability in the region. The Australian dollar (AUD) was also particularly weak, with industrial commodity prices weakening and the region’s strong link to a slowing Chinese economy. In a world of reduced risk appetite, the yen and US dollar (USD) represented relative safe havens.
- The NZD rose by 7% against the euro and 5% against the AUD. The NZD weakened against the other major currencies with an 8% fall against the yen, a 3% fall against the USD and a 2% fall against sterling.
Outlook
From a long term perspective, the NZD is overvalued, but such conditions can be sustained over many years. New Zealand’s strong terms of trade, rising New Zealand-global short term interest rate differential and more favourable fiscal position relative to the major countries, would point to the NZD remaining richly priced for some time to come. That said, the NZD appears to be highly correlated with global shares at the moment, moving up or down in line with risk appetite.
|
|